Damaged checked baggage in package travel: notice, proof of value and compensation

When checked baggage arrives damaged after a flight, travellers should record the damage immediately and notify the responsible parties in writing. The Montreal Convention governs the airline’s baggage liability. For package travel, the Package Travel Act adds a second legal layer. The damage, the timing of the notice, the value of the item and the allocation of the travel services are decisive.

This article covers only damaged checked baggage that formed part of a package travel arrangement. Lost baggage and delayed baggage follow different rules. A damaged suitcase at a hotel or damage caused by a coach operator must also be assessed separately.

Package travel combines at least two different types of travel service for the same trip. Carriage and accommodation are a typical example. Section 2 PRG looks at the booking process, selection, offer and contract documents. The name given to the travel product does not decide the issue by itself.

Checked baggage is primarily connected with the air-carriage service. A suitcase or its contents damaged during carriage therefore requires an initial review of the airline that operated the flight and the baggage documents issued for it. Package travel remains relevant because section 11(1) PRG makes the organiser responsible for the agreed travel services.

Keep the travel confirmation, pre-contract information, flight receipt, baggage receipt, baggage tag and contact details of organiser, intermediary and airline. The overview of package travel and tour operators helps with the first allocation of the contractual roles.

Article 31 of the Montreal Convention requires a written complaint to the carrier when checked baggage is damaged. The complaint generally has to be made within seven days after the baggage was received. A report at the airport creates useful first evidence, but it should be followed by a written notice that can be proven later.

Describe the damage specifically. State the flight number, date, route, baggage number and time of collection. Add photographs and, where available, the baggage office report. Keep the confirmation showing the recipient and time of receipt. A general message saying that the suitcase is broken makes later allocation more difficult.

For package travel, also notify the tour organiser or intermediary of the non-conformity. Section 11(2) PRG requires the traveller to notify the organiser without undue delay of a non-conformity noticed during the trip. Section 13 PRG permits the notice to be made to the intermediary, who must forward it to the organiser. Keep both communication paths verifiable.

The amount of the loss does not follow from the original purchase price alone. The assessment includes the type and extent of damage, repairability, age, condition before the flight and the value of a comparable replacement. A repair estimate or professional assessment may show whether repair is sensible and what it would cost.

Photograph the shell, wheels, handles, seams, fasteners and damaged contents. Add the purchase record, product description, model, year of purchase and relevant insurance documents. For an older item, depreciation or a reduction for prior use may matter. A claim for the price of a new suitcase does not explain that difference.

Record necessary expenditure item by item. This may include an emergency repair, an urgently needed replacement item or shipping a replacement. For each position keep the reason, date, invoice, payment record and connection with the damage. Whether the expenditure is recoverable depends on the circumstances and applicable liability limits.

Regulation (EC) No 889/2002 applied the Montreal Convention liability rules to Community air carriers. Article 17 of the Convention addresses liability for checked baggage where the damaging event occurred during the period of carriage. The operating airline is therefore generally the first party to address for the baggage damage.

For package travel, section 11 PRG must also be considered. The tour organiser remains responsible for the agreed package travel services even where another business operates the flight. Under sections 12(4) and 12(5) PRG, international conventions may limit liability and rights under the PRG may coexist with rights under the Convention. A payment is credited so that the same loss is not compensated twice.

Do not send contradictory or incomplete claims to several parties. Disclose which loss has already been reported or compensated. The organiser or intermediary should forward the notice and assist with the allocation, while the carrier’s specific baggage liability is assessed separately.

Article 22 of the Montreal Convention sets a liability limit per passenger for destruction, loss, damage or delay of baggage. The limit is stated in Special Drawing Rights and may be adjusted. A reliable claim should therefore use the limit applicable at the relevant time. A fixed euro amount from an old article is not a safe basis for calculation.

The limit does not answer every preliminary question. It must first be established that checked baggage was damaged, when the damage may have occurred and which item is affected. Special rules may apply where the damage was caused intentionally or recklessly. A special declaration of value or an additional payment can also change the assessment.

In practice, keep the baggage tag, baggage receipt and every notice until the matter is closed. If the airline offers a fixed amount, compare it with the damage, repair cost, evidence of value and the wording of any settlement statement.

Under section 11(3) PRG, the organiser must remedy a non-conformity where this is possible and does not involve disproportionate cost. A traveller may need an immediate replacement item for the rest of the trip after a suitcase is damaged. Whether the organiser must cover that cost depends on the specific need, cause and further requirements.

A price reduction under section 12(1) PRG concerns a period of the package travel affected by a non-conformity. The physical baggage damage and a resulting financial loss are different positions. Damages under section 12(2) PRG require a specific disadvantage. The international air-carriage rules remain relevant under sections 12(4) and 12(5) PRG.

If you arrange a replacement yourself, first contact an available organiser or travel representative where the situation permits. If immediate action is necessary, record why prior coordination was not possible. Also preserve whether the organiser, airline or insurer has already promised a payment or service.

Arrange the sequence chronologically: booking, check-in, baggage handover, collection at the destination, discovery of damage, notice, response, repair or replacement and final payment. Each stage should be connected with the relevant document. This shows whether the damage may have occurred during carriage and whether notice was timely.

The file should contain the travel confirmation, flight receipt, baggage receipt, baggage tag, photographs, airport report, written notice, responses, repair estimate, purchase or value evidence, invoices and payment records. For damage to contents, also record the packaging and condition at check-in where possible.

The article on package travel complaints and business records shows how travel service, notice, remedy and claim can be kept in chronological order. A single hotel booking or damage to property in a hotel follows different rules. The article on baggage and valuables in a hotel explains that distinction.

Receive new articles and legal guidance from the firm with BRANDaktuelle Rechtsnews. Subscribe to the newsletter.